Chuck Hagel does not like sanctions

Josh Rogin

Former Nebraska Sen. Chuck Hagel, rumored to be incontention for the job of defense secretary, has a long recordof opposing sanctions on countries including Iran, North Korea, Syria, Libya,and Cuba.

Hagel, who serves as co-chair of President Barack Obama's intelligence advisoryboard, throughout his career has publicly supported the idea of engaging withrogue regimes and focusing on diplomacy before punitive measures. While inCongress, he voted against several sanctions measures and argued vociferouslyagainst their effectiveness.

"Engagement is not appeasement. Diplomacy is notappeasement. Great nations engage. Powerful nations must be the adults in worldaffairs. Anything less will result in disastrous, useless, preventable globalconflict," Hagelsaidin a Brookings Institution speech in 2008.

In 2008, Hagel wasblamed for blocking an Iran sanctions bill that SenateDemocrats supported. That same year, hegave a speech calling for the opening of a U.S.diplomatic post in Tehran. As early as 2001, Hagel said that sanctions on Iranand Libya were ineffective. He was one of only two senators that year to voteagainst renewal of the Iran-Libya Sanctions Act, alongwith Sen. Richard Lugar (R-IN).

In his 2008 book, America: Our Next Chapter, Hagel wrote, "America's refusal to recognize Iran's status as a legitimate power doesnot decrease Iran's influence, but rather increases it."

That same year, Hagelpraised the George W. Bush administration's deal with North Korea, which included lifting some sanctions on Pyongyangand removing North Korea from the State Department's list of states thatsponsor terrorism in exchange for greater transparency into North Korea'snuclear program. North Korea later reneged on its side of that bargain.

"Thelast thing we want to do or should do in my opinion is try to isolate NorthKorea," Hagelsaidin 2003. "They are very dangerous, they're unpredictable, and they have a pastbehavior pattern that's a bit erratic. That is not good news for any of us. SoI think we keep the emotions down and keep working the channels."

On Syria, Hagel was a longtime supporter ofengagement with the regime of President Basharal-Assad and his father before him, Hafezal-Assad. Aftermeeting with Assad the elder in 1998, Hagel said, "Peacecomes through dealing with people. Peace doesn't come at the end of a bayonetor the end of a gun."

In 2008, Hagel co-authored a Wall Street Journal op-edwith prospective secretary of state nominee Sen. John Kerry (D-MA), entitled, "It's time to talk to Syria."

"Syria's leaders have always made cold calculationsin the name of self-preservation, and history shows that intensive diplomacycan pay off," Hagel and Kerry wrote.

Hagel has long been a critic of the multi-decade U.S.embargo on Cuba. He has said the trade embargo on Cuba "isolates us, not Cuba,"and voted several times to ease parts of it.

"On Cuba, I've said that we have an outdated,unrealistic, irrelevant policy," hesaidin 2008. "It's always been nonsensical to me about this argument, 'Well, it's acommunist country, it's a communist regime.' What do people think Vietnam is?Or the People's Republic of China? Both those countries are WTO members. Wetrade with them. We have relations. Great powers engage...  Great powers are not afraid. Great powerstrade."

That same year, Hagel signed onto aletter to Secretary State Condoleezza Rice urging her to alter U.S.-Cuba policy. In 2002,Hagel called then leader Fidel Castro a "toothless old dinosaur" and said heagreed with former U.S. president Jimmy Carter on Cuba.

"What Jimmy Carter's saying ... is exactly right:Our 40-year policy toward Cuba is senseless," Hagel said.

In 2000, Hagel fought against legislation that wouldhave granted citizenship to Cuban refugee ElianGonzales.

17 Dec 2012

Chuck Hagel does not like sanctions

thecable.foreignpolicy.com | Josh Rogin | 2012-12-17 16:51:03

Former Nebraska Sen. Chuck Hagel, rumored to be incontention for the job of defense secretary, has a long recordof opposing sanctions on countries including Iran, North Korea, Syria, Libya,and Cuba.Hagel, who serves as co-chair of President Barack Obama's intelligence advisoryboard, throughout his career has publicly supported the idea of engaging withrogue regimes and focusing on diplomacy before punitive measures. While inCongress, he voted against several sanctions measures and argued vociferouslyagainst their effectiveness."Engagement is not appeasement. Diplomacy is notappeasement. G... Similar >>

Menendez and Hagel on opposite sides of Iran issue

thecable.foreignpolicy.com | Josh Rogin | 2012-12-19 15:41:37

If ChuckHagel is selected as President Obama's next defense secretary, the formerNebraska senator could find himself battling the new head of the Senate ForeignRelations Committee (SFRC), Sen. RobertMenendez (D-NJ) on the fraught issueof how to deal with Iran -- that is if Sen. John Kerry (D-MA) leaves that committee to become secretary ofstate.The White House is expected to announce its newnational security nominations as early as this Friday, Dec. 21, depending on howthe president's "fiscal cliff" negotiations are proceeding with House Speaker John Boehner.Why not earlier? Kerry is... Similar >>

Republican senators were for Hagel, before they were against him

thecable.foreignpolicy.com | Josh Rogin | 2012-12-28 23:02:25

A growing number of GOP senators have expressedconcerns about the potential nomination of ChuckHagel to be Obama's next secretary of defense, but only four years ago manyof these same Republicans praised Hagel as a statesman and even suggested hewould make a good cabinet official. SHARE: More... White House sources insist that President Barack Obama hasn't made his finaldecision on whom he will choose to succeed LeonPanetta at the Pentagon. Hagel, the former Nebraska senator and currentco-chair of Obama's intelligence advisory board, has been fully vetted... Similar >>

Sen. Marco Rubio on Hagel Nomination for Defense Secretary: “I Just Don’t Believe I Will be Able to Support His Nomination” – Video 1/31/13

freedomslighthouse.net | Brian | 2013-02-01 03:28:10
Here is video of Sen. Marco Rubio today commenting on Chuck Hagel’s nomination for Secretary of Defense. Rubio said while he appreciates Hagel’s service in Vietnam, “I just don’t believe I will be able to support his nomination.” Rubio cited Hagel’s statements on Israel, North Korea and Iran as key factors in his decision.Similar >>

Soccer Dad's Mideast Media Sampler, 1/9/13

joshuapundit.blogspot.com | | 2013-01-10 01:50:21

Today's sampler and analysis of Mideast media content from my pal Soccer Dad:1) Cabinet makingIn 2008, on the campaign trail, candidate Barack Obama flattered himself by evoking Abraham Lincoln and promising a cabinet composed of a "team of rivals."Now headed into his second term he has proposed three new officials for his government. The Washington Post sees this as an opportunity for A Senate Debate on Mr. Obama's foreign policy. The editorial works from the assumption that John Brennan and Senators John Kerry and Chuck Hagel are qualified and should confirmed as Director of Central Int... Similar >>

The Obama administration's troubling history of politicizing intelligence

shadow.foreignpolicy.com | Kori Schake | 2013-05-01 03:39:08

For months, the Obama administration has been avoiding the conclusion that the Assad government usedchemical weapons in its armed struggle to suppress its citizens. As recently asyesterday, Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel rebuffed the notion, saying"suspicions are one thing; evidence is another." Today the White House finally conceded the point. "Ourintelligence community does assess with varying degrees of confidence that theSyrian regime has used chemical weapons on a small scale in Syria, specificallythe chemical agent Sarin," the administration wrote in a letter to Congre... Similar >>

The Hagel hearings and the Iran use of force question

shadow.foreignpolicy.com | Peter Feaver | 2013-01-08 19:24:24

Isit possible that the debate and vote on Senator Hagel's confirmation for secretary of defense will be the closest the Senate comes to a debate and voteon the use of force in Iran?  As the administration showed on Libya,President Obama believes he can use military force without a prior congressional vote. The administration would be very wary about askingfor something it is not absolutely certain it could get, and it would have tobe very uncertain of winning such an "authorization to use militaryforce in Iran" vote. Accordingly, it is likely that, if it ever cameto it, the Obama adm... Similar >>

The Hagel hearings and the Iran use of force question (updated)

thecable.foreignpolicy.com | Peter Feaver | 2013-01-23 16:47:38

Isit possible that the debate and vote on Senator Hagel's confirmation for secretary of defense will be the closest the Senate comes to a debate and voteon the use of force in Iran?  As the administration showed on Libya,President Obama believes he can use military force without a prior congressional vote. The administration would be very wary about askingfor something it is not absolutely certain it could get, and it would have tobe very uncertain of winning such an "authorization to use militaryforce in Iran" vote. Accordingly, it is likely that, if it ever cameto it, the Obama adm... Similar >>

Senator Rubio-Hagel Has “Big,Big Problems,” Will Not Support Nomination

shark-tank.net | Javier Manjarres | 2013-01-31 14:35:25
By Javier Manjarres   U.S. Senator Marco Rubio has just announced that he will not be supporting former Senator Chuck Hagel, as Secretary of Defense. During a live interview on Fox News, just moments ago, Rubio stated he was “deeply concerned” about Hagel’s  previous statement in regards to sanctions on Iran, negotiating with North Korean, [...]Similar >>

An open letter to the New York Times concerning Thomas Friedman

Dear New York Times: As the paper of record, your op-ed page is a natural target for snark, derision, and other forms of criticism.  I'll certainly plead guilty to these venal sins. I've found flaws in more than a few of your columnist's writings on foreign affairs.  Thomas Friedman, in particular, has invited a fair measure of scorn from your correspondent over the years -- though I'd note that I'm hardly the only one guilty of that sin.  Let me stipulate that I have no doubt that Mr. Friedman can polish off an accessible 800 word column on foreign affairs better than 99.5% of the foreign pol... Similar >>

Obama's Chance to Do Something Right: Nominate Hagel for Secretary of Defense; Why the War Party Fears Hagel

globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com | | 2013-01-07 03:10:41
The Financial Time reports Hagel nomination expected this week.US President Barack Obama is poised to nominate Chuck Hagel as secretary of defence, setting the stage for a tough nomination fight focusing on the former Republican senator’s views on Israel and Iran.The announcement by Mr Obama of a new Pentagon chief to replace Leon Panetta could come as early as Monday, administration officials indicated. Mr Obama returned from a holiday in Hawaii on Sunday.Mr Hagel’s possible nomination has caused an uproar among neoconservatives over his questioning of sanctions and military action against Ir... Similar >>

Rand Paul ‘open-minded’ on Hagel

thecable.foreignpolicy.com | Josh Rogin | 2013-01-08 02:32:02
Sen. Rand Paul(R-KY), one of the new Republicans on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee,has no plans to oppose the nominations either of former Sen. Chuck Hagel to be the next defense secretaryor current Sen. John Kerry (D-MA) tobe the next secretary of state, he told TheCable in an interview."I'm going to remain open-minded and hear more about what[Hagel's] plans are and his direction are as he comes forward. I'm not going tomake a prior commitment one way or the other," Paul said.The firm opposition to Hagel has now risen to include fiveGOP senators. Sen. David Vitter(R-LA) anno... Similar >>

Rand Paul ‘open-minded’ on Hagel

walt.foreignpolicy.com | Josh Rogin | 2013-01-23 16:47:47
Sen. Rand Paul(R-KY), one of the new Republicans on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee,has no plans to oppose the nominations either of former Sen. Chuck Hagel to be the next defense secretaryor current Sen. John Kerry (D-MA) tobe the next secretary of state, he told TheCable in an interview."I'm going to remain open-minded and hear more about what[Hagel's] plans are and his direction are as he comes forward. I'm not going tomake a prior commitment one way or the other," Paul said.The firm opposition to Hagel has now risen to include fiveGOP senators. Sen. David Vitter(R-LA) anno... Similar >>

Senate Confirmations: An Opportunity Squandered

www.unitedliberty.org | tthornton | 2013-02-06 15:11:31

President Obama’s foreign policy team is undergoing a makeover, with the nominations of Senator John Kerry as Secretary of State, former Nebraska Republican Senator Chuck Hagel as Secretary of Defense, and the Deputy National Security Advisor John Brennan as CIA Director.  All three gentlemen are expected to be confirmed; Kerry already has, Hagel will likely be confirmed (following an abysmal hearing) later this week, and Brennan faces his confirmation hearing this Thursday, which will essentially be the GOP’s final chance to hold Obama accountable for broken national security policies. The G... Similar >>

Chuck Hagel: America shouldn’t be in the lead on Syria, not time to attack Iran

thecable.foreignpolicy.com | Josh Rogin | 2012-12-15 15:06:39

The American people are weary of war and aren't up foranother military adventure in either Syria or Iran, former Nebraska senator andpotential defense secretary Chuck Hageltold The Cable.Hagel sat down for a 90-minute exclusiveinterview in his Georgetown office in May, well before President Barack Obama beganvetting him for a top national security position in his second-termcabinet, perhaps to replace Leon Panettaat the Pentagon. In previously unreleased portions of that interview, Hagelcommented on how the United States should move forward in Syria and Iran,urging caution, patience, and a foc... Similar >>

Some 2013 Predictions

www.unitedliberty.org | Kevin Boyd | 2013-01-02 13:52:51
It’s that time of year when I take a stab at guessing what will happen in the new year. Just like always, I will take a stab at national politics, international politics, the economy, and sports.Here’s how I did last year.National*There will be a debt ceiling fight. America’s credit worthiness will be downgraded. Ultimately, the debt ceiling will be raised with no real spending cuts or entitlement reforms.*No gun control legislation will pass this year on the Federal level. However, the left will embark on a cultural campaign against gun ownership in general.*Minor filibuster reform will... Similar >>

Hagel Pick Could Come Monday

politicalwire.com | | 2013-01-07 03:10:55

President Obama will nominate former Sen. Chuck Hagel (R-NE) to be his defense secretary, and an announcement could come on Monday, Reuters reports."The choice will likely set up a confirmation battle in the Senate over whether the former Nebraska senator strongly supports key U.S. ally Israel. Hagel also has been criticized for comments he made questioning the effectiveness of sanctions on Iran for its nuclear program."Marc Ambinder: Why Hagel?Similar >>

Obama's 'strategic patience' on North Korea is turning into strategic neglect

shadow.foreignpolicy.com | William Tobey | 2013-02-14 15:29:02

When asked,"would you be willing to meet separately, without precondition, during thefirst year of your administration, in Washington or anywhere else, with theleaders of Iran, Syria, Venezuela, Cuba and North Korea, in order to bridge thegap that divides our countries?" then-candidate for President Barack Obamareplied, "I would." Thatanswer is little noted, nor long remembered. Yet the challenges posed by NorthKorea and Iran's nuclear programs have only grown. Since President Obama tookoffice, North Korea has conducted two more nuclear tests, the latest on the eveof the St... Similar >>

Russian foreign minister won’t return Kerry’s call

thecable.foreignpolicy.com | Josh Rogin | 2013-02-14 12:48:42

Secretary of State John Kerry called all the foreign ministers of countries that dealwith North Korea following Monday's nuclear test and all but one of them pickedup the phone -- Russian Foreign Minister SergeiLavrov. SHARE: More... Speaking to reporters Wednesday, Kerry made hisfirst remarks about the new nuclear test, which the North Koreans warnedthe State Department about in advance."With respect to the DPRK, President Obama made it crystal clear last nightand previously in all comments, as have other countries, that North Korea'snuclear weapons... Similar >>

Time is Running Out in Syria

shadow.foreignpolicy.com | Dov Zakheim | 2013-04-20 04:23:48

Onceagain, international events are intruding upon the administration'sdetermination to focus on domestic policy. To no one's surprise, exceptperhaps, that of the White House, Iran once again has signaled that it is notinterested in serious negotiations unless all sanctions, presumably to includethose imposed for its support of terrorism and violations of basic human rights,are lifted forthwith. In the meantime, North Korea's secular monarch, KimJong Un, has sparked a new crisis on the peninsula by ratcheting up hisnation's bellicosity to fever pitch. And lastly, the Syrian government appearst... Similar >>